Brooklyn building collapse: injured workers sue developer, contractors and engineers over shoring
Five workers for subcontractor W.G. NY Construction Corp. who were hurt in the Nov. 11 Brooklyn building collapse at 1321 Flatbush Ave. have sued eight parties for negligence, the New York Daily News reported. Theirs is one of five lawsuits filed in Brooklyn Supreme Court so far.
The five say masonry and pieces of interior walls struck them when the three-story building next to their jobsite came down around 4 p.m. Their complaint argues the defendants were obliged to put retaining walls and shoring around the whole excavation. Instead, the suit says, digging went on beside an old building whose facade was already cracking. The collapse killed eight people, two of them children, and injured 18.
LMW Engineering Group, which prepared the support-of-excavation plans filed with the city's Department of Buildings, is among the eight defendants. The suit claims its engineer skipped adequate field inspections and surveys of the soil and the neighboring buildings, and set aside a peer engineer's advice to underpin every building touching the site, the one that fell included.
Other injured workers have gone to court separately. Two, represented by Hecht, Kleeger & Damashek, filed suits on Wednesday against the developer, the general contractor, another construction firm and the fallen building's owner. A 52-year-old who worked at the site for Elite Concrete and was partly buried, with injuries to a knee, his lower back and an arm, filed an amended complaint on Tuesday against six parties. A tenant who lost his apartment sued on Monday.
These are allegations that no court has tested. Three defendants declined to comment to the Daily News, and the rest did not respond. The city has not announced a cause for the collapse.
Why it matters: On a dig next to an occupied building, the support-of-excavation plan, the underpinning decisions and any crack reports are the first papers lawyers will ask for. Subcontractors' own crews are now among the plaintiffs, which puts the shoring design in front of a jury from both sides.
Sources
- Construction workers hurt in deadly Brooklyn building collapse sue over ‘negligence’New York Daily News, Nov 19