Edition
Sunday, November 22
Updated
1:06 PM EST

Fails & scandals

Brooklyn building collapse: stop-work orders hit five sites tied to the dig's engineers as a tenant sues

New York City inspectors have fully or partly stopped work at five or more jobsites linked to LMW Engineering Group and RI Consulting Services, the engineering firms on the Flatbush dig beside the Brooklyn building collapse, Gothamist reported. A tenant of the fallen building has filed a lawsuit.

Since the Nov. 11 collapse at 1321 Flatbush Ave., which killed eight people, the Department of Buildings has visited at least 24 jobsites in four boroughs connected to the two firms, according to a Gothamist review of city records. New Jersey-based LMW drew the excavation and support-of-excavation plans for the lot next door at 2625 Bedford Ave. Queens-based RI Consulting was the special inspector monitoring the excavation and shoring there. Its principal asked to withdraw from the project a day after the collapse, and the department has not approved that request, Gothamist reported.

Most of the orders deal with general site safety rather than digging. Inspectors stopped exterior work at a garage-to-condo conversion at 332 West 11th St. in Greenwich Village over unsafe scaffolding, and at 1021 Summit Ave. in the Bronx over scaffolding that failed city code. They halted some interior work at a six-story building at 56-12 Roosevelt Ave. in Woodside after spotting a worker on scaffolding with no harness, and facade work at 54-47 Little Neck Parkway in Douglaston over loose netting and missing guardrails. At 58 West 184th St. in the Bronx, where RI Consulting designed the excavation support, a partial order became a full one on Tuesday after the general contractor refused an inspector entry. The department declined to give details of the sweep.

The lawsuit, filed Monday night in state Supreme Court in Brooklyn, comes from a tenant who lost his home. He claims he photographed cracks near the entrance in October and told the landlord, who answered that the problem was not his fault or could not be fixed. Defendants include the owner's company, Isolag Realty Corp., the LLCs that own the construction lot, general contractor Townhouse Builders, subcontractor Elite Concrete, LMW and RI Consulting. These are allegations, and none of the defendants responded to Gothamist.

The cause is still undetermined. ENR found that public records do not show whether 1321 Flatbush had been underpinned or how deep the excavation went. The approved plans required baseline readings and ongoing monitoring of movement, cracks and vibration, but that data and the special inspection reports have not been released.

Earlier: Brooklyn building collapse that killed eight brings inspections at 160 sites tied to the dig next door

Why it matters: If LMW Engineering or RI Consulting is on your drawings or inspection sign-offs, expect inspectors, and they are writing up scaffolding, netting and harness lapses too. Keep monitoring readings and special inspection reports current and ready to show.

Sources

More in fails & scandals