Brooklyn building collapse: excavator Elite Concrete drew a crack complaint and a gas main citation this year
Elite Concrete, the Williamsburg company digging the pit beside the Brooklyn building that collapsed on Nov. 11, was the subject of a neighbor's 311 complaint about foundation cracks at a Bronx job in March and a state citation for hitting a gas main there in May, The City Reporter found.
At 2167 Arthur Ave. in the Bronx, a neighbor called 311 to say Elite's excavation had left cracks in the foundation of his house, according to Buildings Department records reviewed by the outlet. Inspectors came two days later and issued no violations. Two months later, state utility regulators at the Public Service Commission penalized Elite after its crew struck a 6-inch gas main on the Bronx lot; they found the crew dug before calling the one-call center that would have marked the line. The city's Construction Safety Enforcement unit visited Arthur Avenue on Friday. One of the three laborers killed in the Flatbush pit was an Elite employee. Elite did not return calls, the outlet said.
N Tech Design of America, which demolished the old structure on the Bedford Avenue lot, has records at other Brooklyn jobs. At 285 and 291 Eastern Parkway the department has written seven violations since February and stopped work twice, once over missing protection from falling debris for the building next door. At 599 Willoughby Ave., a former church becoming 10 apartments, N Tech has drawn 13 violations since July and a full vacate order after bricks landed in a neighbor's yard. An N Tech representative said its demolition ended in May, on a slab with no basement, and had nothing to do with the dig.
Inspectors also checked a Midwood job of general contractor Townhouse Builders on Saturday and Monday. A Buildings Department spokesperson said the sweep of about 160 sites continues and results are coming. Investigators are looking at whether Elite dug past what was approved: the developer, W6 Facilities X LLC, had a permit for three stories but had filed unapproved plans for nine that needed a deeper hole. The department, the Department of Investigation and the Brooklyn District Attorney are investigating. No cause has been announced and no one has been charged.
Why it matters: A neighbor's crack complaint drew no violations, and digging went on. If you excavate next to old buildings, log every complaint, get the one-call ticket before you dig and keep monitoring data current: New York inspectors are now pulling contractors' past records job by job.
Sources
- Investigators Swarm Construction Sites Tied to Contractors in Fatal Flatbush CollapseThe City Reporter, Nov 18
- City stops construction at sites tied to engineers in fatal Brooklyn collapseThe Real Deal, Nov 18