Edition
Sunday, November 22
Updated
1:06 PM EST

Fails & scandals

Brooklyn building collapse: city says the dig plans met its rules as injured workers move to sue

New York City's Department of Buildings told the Associated Press it reviewed the excavation and support plans for 2625 Bedford Ave. and found they met city requirements. Checking what was actually built falls partly to private inspectors that developers hire, the agency said.

The department gave the answer by email on Friday, nine days after the three-story building at 1321 Flatbush Ave. fell into the excavation next door and killed eight people. Several injured workers have taken first steps toward a lawsuit against the department, the AP reported. That would add the city to suits already filed against the site owner, the contractors, the excavation engineer and the owner of the building that fell. Brooklyn prosecutors are investigating, and the department is hiring an independent engineering consultant.

The department did not answer the AP's question on whether it responded to a preconstruction survey that rated the adjoining wall of the collapsed building as in poor condition, with visible cracks. That survey was filed with the city in March, FOX 5 New York reported, about the same time inspectors stopped demolition at the site for missing overhead protection over the neighbors.

A suit by five injured workers claims the dig lacked adequate retaining walls, shoring and underpinning, and that excavation went on after the facade began to crack. The building that fell was close to a century old and carried more than 90 open housing code violations. The AP also counted at least a dozen lawsuits that blamed excavation plans drawn by LMW Engineering Group, the project's excavation engineer, for damage to neighboring buildings in earlier jobs. The firm denied the claims in the 2015 and 2016 cases, and other suits were settled out of court. None of the claims has been proven.

The city is also checking more than 160 construction sites tied to companies on the Bedford Avenue project. Excavation there began with city permits in September.

Earlier: Brooklyn building collapse: injured workers sue developer, contractors and engineers over shoring

Why it matters: Plan approval says nothing about what went into the hole. On a dig beside an old building, owners and GCs should know which special inspector signs off on underpinning and excavation support, and who acts when a preconstruction survey flags cracks.

Sources

More in fails & scandals