Edition
Sunday, November 22
Updated
1:06 PM EST

Fails & scandalsIN

Garden Reach building collapse: Calcutta High Court keeps murder charge against promoter over 15 deaths

The Calcutta High Court has refused to drop murder and attempted murder charges against the promoter of the illegal five-storey building that collapsed in Kolkata's Garden Reach area in March 2024, killing 15 people. He had argued he only financed the project.

Justice Chaitali Chatterjee Das dismissed the promoter's revision petition against charges framed by a sessions court in Alipore, LiveLaw reported. The charges include murder, attempted murder and criminal conspiracy under the Indian Penal Code. His lawyers said the evidence showed no intent or knowledge that would support a murder count and that a co-accused, who died in the collapse, ran the site day to day. The judge said changing the charges this early could cripple the prosecution's case, and that the trial court will decide his guilt on the evidence.

The charge sheet says the promoter chose poor materials, and witnesses told police he had laborers mix concrete in the wrong proportions for the columns, the court noted. It added that he took an active part in the construction with no technical training. An interim report by experts from Jadavpur University, who tested debris, concrete and rebar, found the concrete quality doubtful, the columns smaller than the Indian Standard minimum and the steel short of the required yield and ultimate strength.

The building at Azhar Molla Bagan went up without approval from the Kolkata Municipal Corporation. Work began in December 2022 on a plot of about three cottahs, roughly 2,160 square feet, with four two-bedroom flats planned on each floor. It came down on the night of March 17, 2024, and crushed neighboring single-storey homes. Police charged the promoter and five others in a 730-page charge sheet naming 170 witnesses, IANS reported in June 2024. In April 2024 the High Court ordered the city to suspend and discipline officials who let the illegal work go on, PTI reported, and IANS later reported that three civil engineers in the corporation's building department had been suspended.

Why it matters: Courts are willing to put builders of illegal floors on trial for murder, and here the evidence is basic: column sizes, mix ratios and rebar strength. Anyone who pours columns should keep mix tickets, rebar mill certificates and approved drawings on file.

Sources

More in fails & scandals