Edition
Sunday, November 22
Updated
1:06 PM EST

Business

Labor Department final rule makes it easier to treat workers as independent contractors

The US Labor Department issued a final rule on Nov. 19 that throws out its 2024 test for sorting employees from independent contractors and goes back to a framework close to the 2021 version, built on two core factors: control over the work and the chance of profit or loss.

Labor Secretary Keith Sonderling and Wage and Hour Division chief Andrew Rogers presented the rule at the department's headquarters in Washington. It applies to the Fair Labor Standards Act, the federal minimum wage and overtime law, and to two laws that borrow its definition of employment: the Family and Medical Leave Act and the Migrant and Seasonal Agricultural Worker Protection Act. Ogletree Deakins, a management-side law firm, wrote that it takes effect 60 days after it appears in the Federal Register.

The test asks one question: does the worker run a business of his or her own, or depend on the company for work? Two factors weigh most, the department says. One is how much say the worker has over the job, such as setting hours, choosing projects and taking work from competitors. The other is whether the worker can earn more or lose money through initiative or investment. Skill, how lasting the relationship is and whether the work fits into an integrated production unit also count. What both sides do in practice matters more than what a contract allows on paper.

The department published its proposal on Feb. 27 and drew more than 16,000 comments. The final text keeps most of it and offers 14 worked examples, with new ones on farm labor contractors, app-based workers and truck drivers. HR Dive called it the latest swing in a standard that has changed hands with each administration.

The rule does not touch how the IRS classifies workers, and it does not override state or local law, the department says. Ogletree noted that some state tests are stricter and that the rule may be challenged in court.

Why it matters: A contractor paying framing, drywall or tile crews on 1099s gets a federal test that leans on control and profit or loss. State wage laws and the IRS keep their own tests, so a crew that passes the federal one can still count as employees elsewhere.

Sources

More in business