Edition
Sunday, November 22
Updated
1:06 PM EST

BusinessUK

Bouygues UK can pursue its challenge to the £15.4 billion DfE schools framework, judge rules

Bouygues (U.K.) Limited filed its claim against the Department for Education in time, the High Court ruled on November 19, so the contractor's challenge to losing a place on the £15.4 billion Construction Framework 25 by 0.13 points goes ahead.

Bouygues bid for Lot 2 of the schools framework, where the department planned to appoint the 10 highest-ranked contractors. It finished 11th with 74.67 points. McLaren Construction took the last place with 74.8, according to the judgment by Mr Justice Coppel in the Technology and Construction Court. One mark more for Bouygues on any question, or one fewer for McLaren, would have flipped the result, the court noted.

The department argued the claim was out of time. Under the Procurement Act 2023, a supplier has 30 days to start proceedings, and the government said that window closed on Saturday, January 3. Bouygues lodged its claim form electronically at 4:18 p.m. on Monday, January 5. The judge found the 30 days began on December 5, 2025, the day the assessment summary went out, and ended on January 5, so the claim was in time. He added that he would have extended the deadline anyway.

The fight over scoring is still to come. Bouygues says evaluators wrongly marked down several answers, including one on nature-based solutions where it got 2 out of 10, and it challenges how scores were moderated and recorded. The court has not ruled on any of that. The framework itself is already signed: no automatic suspension took effect, because Bouygues told the department about its claim only after the extended standstill period had run out. The Construction Enquirer reported that the judge signaled damages were a likelier outcome than a seat on the framework.

Why it matters: Losing bidders on UK public contracts should count the 30-day window from the day the assessment summary arrives, and file before standstill ends to stop the contract being signed. Close scores open the door to a claim, but a place on the framework is hard to win back.

Sources

More in business