Edition
Sunday, November 22
Updated
1:06 PM EST

Business

Cal/OSHA proposes rules for enterprise-wide and egregious citations, with a hearing on Dec. 3

California's Division of Occupational Safety and Health has published draft rules that would let it cite an employer for a hazard repeated across several worksites and fine willful violators once per exposed worker. Written comments are due Nov. 30, and the public hearing is Dec. 3 in Oakland and on Zoom.

The rules put into practice SB 606, a law signed in 2021 that added two new classes of violation to the Labor Code. According to the notice of proposed action from the Department of Industrial Relations, the draft defines both classes and spells out how Cal/OSHA would calculate the penalties.

An enterprise-wide violation would be presumed when an employer has workers at more than one site and either a written policy covering several sites breaks a safety standard, or inspectors find a pattern of the same violation at more than one location. The penalty would be multiplied by the number of worksites the citation covers, with a cap of $162,851.

An egregious violation starts as a willful one. It becomes egregious when, within the past five years, the employer has at least one repeat or willful violation, five serious ones or ten general ones on record, or shows clear bad faith, for example by running no working injury and illness prevention program. A fatality, a catastrophe with three or more workers hospitalized, five or more injuries, or an experience modifier above 125% also qualify. Each exposed employee would then bring a separate citation and penalty. Willful penalties already range from $11,632 to $162,851 apiece.

The department's economic analysis shows what that means. A $10,000 penalty with 10 workers exposed becomes $100,000. In its review of 2023 willful citations, one against a commercial building contractor with 36 exposed workers carried $10,981 and would have reached $395,316 under the new method. The draft also stretches the look-back on an employer's violation history from three years to five. The department puts the added penalties at about $1.18 million a year. After the hearing the director can adopt the text or change it with a 15-day notice.

Why it matters: For a GC or sub running several California jobs, one flawed company-wide document, such as a fall protection or heat illness plan, could be cited at every site at once. Review written programs and your injury and illness prevention program now, and send comments by Nov. 30 if the draft worries you.

Sources

More in business