Edition
Sunday, November 22
Updated
1:06 PM EST

Fails & scandals

Brooklyn building collapse: city-approved dig plan gave the building that fell no bracing

The excavation plan New York's Department of Buildings approved in March for 2625 Bedford Avenue braced every neighboring building except 1321 Flatbush Avenue, the three-story walk-up that slid into the pit on Nov. 11 and killed eight, Gothamist and the New York Post report from city records.

On that side, the drawings called for cutting the soil back at roughly 45 degrees to a depth of about 15 feet, Gothamist reported. Steel rakers were shown against every other adjoining building. The Post reported that the site's November 2025 geotechnical report expected lot-line buildings to need underpinning and found loose beach and dune sand down to 42 feet. The 94-year-old building stood on a rubble foundation less than eight feet deep, and the dig was planned to go about twice that.

Engineers who looked at the plans for both outlets said they would have expected underpinning or bracing there. One engineer from RAND Engineering & Architecture told Gothamist that steel is not always required if the cut stays clear of the neighbor's footing. The Department of Buildings called the sloped cut, known as benching, standard practice and said the plans passed a full exam. It said the engineer of record answers for their safety and that it is now reviewing the geotechnical report again.

Other records show earlier trouble. The demolition contractor, N Tech Design of America, drew a $10,000 violation in April for working through a stop-work order and a $2,500 one in March for demolishing without overhead protection for neighbors, Brownstoner reported. A complaint filed with the city after the collapse asks whether a subcontractor opened too long a stretch along the old foundation at once, instead of the short sections the shoring drawings set out. The special inspector hired to watch the excavation has asked to leave the job, according to Gothamist.

The Department of Buildings, the Department of Investigation and the Brooklyn District Attorney are investigating. No cause has been announced and no one has been charged.

Earlier: Brooklyn building collapse that killed eight brings inspections at 160 sites tied to the dig next door

Why it matters: Before a crew digs beside an old building on a rubble footing, put the excavation drawings next to the soil report. If the geotech calls for underpinning and the plans don't show it, get that settled in writing first.

Sources

More in fails & scandals