Edition
Sunday, November 22
Updated
1:06 PM EST

Fails & scandals

Brooklyn building collapse: Townhouse Builders, GC on the dig next door, was sued in 2020 over excavation damage

Townhouse Builders Inc., the general contractor that also trades as Promont and ran the excavation beside the Flatbush Avenue building that fell on November 11, was accused in a 2020 lawsuit of cracking and destabilizing neighboring buildings on an earlier Brooklyn job, Realtor.com reported. That case is still open.

The suit was brought in Kings County Supreme Court by the developer behind 1200 Broadway, a six-story hotel project in Bedford-Stuyvesant that hired Townhouse as GC in 2016, according to court records reviewed by Realtor.com. It claims that digging, underpinning and pile driving there damaged the developer's lot and the buildings at 1196 Broadway and at 15 and 17 Patchen Avenue, and that the contractor never surveyed or braced the neighboring walls before starting. The developer seeks more than $1.1 million. The claims are unproven, and the next hearing is set for January 2027.

Buildings Department records for the hotel job show three violations against Townhouse in 2016 and 2017. Two were for not monitoring adjoining structures for movement and cracks while digging. The third, an immediately hazardous Class 1 violation, followed an excavator bucket striking a neighbor's brick foundation wall. The fines came to $10,400, Realtor.com reported, and it counted 67 lawsuits naming Townhouse or Promont since 2012, with 13 still open and most apparently over jobsite injuries. The company did not answer Realtor.com.

The Buildings Department told Construction Dive it has widened its safety sweep to six companies at more than 160 sites and will hire an outside engineering firm to write an independent report. The Bedford Avenue job only had approval for below-grade work: earthwork, foundations and support of excavation. The cause of the collapse, which killed eight people, has not been determined, and the Brooklyn District Attorney has opened a criminal investigation. No one has been charged.

Earlier: Brooklyn building collapse: city-approved dig plan gave the building that fell no bracing

Why it matters: New York requires contractors to monitor adjoining buildings during excavation, and missing that is exactly what the city cited on this firm's earlier job. Keep movement and crack readings on file for every dig beside an occupied building, and check an excavation contractor's DOB record before hiring.

Sources

More in fails & scandals