Almacantar loses appeal to charge Centre Point House leaseholders for a £12 million facade replacement
The Court of Appeal has ruled that Almacantar, freeholder of Centre Point House in central London, cannot pass the cost of replacing the building's rotting 1960s facade, expected to top £12 million, to leaseholders with qualifying leases under the Building Safety Act 2022.
Centre Point House is the six-storey podium next to the Centre Point tower, with 36 duplex flats. Its experimental timber-framed glazed facade has let water in for decades and the frames have rotted; one casement panel has already fallen, Solicitors Journal reported. Experts for both sides agreed the only workable fix is a new steel curtain wall fixed to the concrete frame.
Almacantar argued that the Act protects leaseholders only from relevant defects, a term tied to work done in the 30 years before June 28, 2022. The facade was built between 1963 and 1966. Lords Justices Newey, Miles and Fancourt dismissed the appeal on all five grounds in [2026] EWCA Civ 1466, upholding the First-tier Tribunal and the Upper Tribunal. They held that the cladding paragraph of Schedule 8 does not refer to relevant defects, and that "unsafe" is an ordinary word that covers dangers other than fire.
Leaseholders without qualifying leases still owe their share under the landlord's repair covenants, the First-tier Tribunal found. The Court of Appeal left open whether a cladding system that makes up the whole external wall, such as modern curtain walling, would also be covered.
Julia Tobbell of Forsters, which acted for one leaseholder, told Property Week the decision will matter for unusual cladding found unsafe for reasons other than fire risk. Almacantar declined to comment. The Supreme Court is due to hear two more disputes over Building Safety Act repair costs this week, involving Hippersley Point in south London and Triathlon Homes in east London.
Why it matters: The ruling widens the facade defects UK landlords cannot bill to qualifying leaseholders, including old cladding that is dangerous for reasons other than fire. On remediation jobs like this one, the freeholder carries the cost, which changes who funds and signs the contract.
Sources
- Tribunal dismisses Almacantar's BSA appeal to recover Centre Point leaseholder costsProperty Week, Nov 17
- Almacantar v de Valk: Court of Appeal confirms cladding protection not limited to relevant defectsSolicitors Journal, Nov 17