Three shower waterproofing systems built side by side, and where each one fails
Home RenoVision DIY built three identical 3-by-5-foot showers to compare an acrylic pan, a foam pan with a bonded membrane and a tile-ready base, then backed the walls with drywall, cement board, a sheet membrane and a liquid membrane.
The renovation channel left tile and finish work out of the test. Every stall is the standard 3 by 5 feet, so the only thing that changes is what sits behind the tile. The host opens with the point of the exercise: a shower that leaks costs more than any upgrade.
The acrylic pan is the cheapest option because it is the base and the finish in one. Its weak spot is the drain. If the floor flexes there, the acrylic cracks, so the crew bedded it in mortar and pre-drilled every flange screw. The host puts a refinishing call at $300 to $400. The Schluter foam tray comes with its membrane attached, but its slope is the bare code minimum, so the subfloor got self-leveler first and the tray was pressed into thinset without sliding, since a dent will hold water. The tile-ready base is one rigid, pre-sloped piece with a curb and cannot be dented.
On the walls, mold-resistant drywall behind a one-piece acrylic surround up to 70 inches met the minimum the host works to. Tile needs more: taped joints and a membrane. Cement board needs its own coated screws, because the alkaline board corrodes drywall screws. The crew covered it with a fabric sheet membrane in thinset, and covered the drywall with two coats of a roll-on liquid membrane at about $70 a gallon. On foam wall board sealed with Kerdi-Band, he warned that thinset ridges left uncollapsed under tile trap water that builds pressure and rots the wall. His fix is prefabricated inside corners set behind the board, lapped like step flashing.
US guidance agrees on most points. The Energy Department's Building America Solution Center says cement board resists water without being waterproof and should get a fluid-applied coating, edges included. Paper-faced board is acceptable there only behind a one-piece enclosure with no seams. San Diego's code bulletin requires shower wall finish to at least 72 inches above the drain inlet.
Why it matters: Most shower callbacks start behind the tile. Check that the subfloor is level before setting a foam tray, use the board maker's coated screws on cement board, and collapse every thinset ridge when tiling over a bonded membrane.
Sources
- I Tested All the Best (and Worst) Ways to Build a ShowerHome RenoVision DIY, Nov 21
- Cement Board Installed Behind Tile and Panel Tub and Shower EnclosuresBuilding America Solution Center, Nov 21
- Floor and Wall Finishes in Toilet, Bath and Shower SpacesCity of San Diego, Nov 21