First pinhole leak in old copper pipe: patch it or repipe the house
The owner of a 40-year-old house asked on Reddit whether one pinhole leak in the copper water lines means it is time to repipe. The answer turns on why the pipe failed, and the cause can be traced before anyone opens a wall.
The question came up on Reddit's r/Plumbing forum. The leak had been fixed, and the owner was surprised the pipe looked so ordinary around the hole. That fits how copper fails, according to This Old House: the damage starts inside, where a thin protective layer forms on the bore once water runs through it. When that layer breaks down, the metal underneath corrodes.
This Old House lists the usual causes. Soldering flux left in the lines can attack the pipe if the system sits unused after installation, most often near fittings and on cold lines, since hot water washes flux out better. Water moving too fast scours the layer away, and badly prepared pipe ends cause turbulence. Rust from a water heater whose anode rod has worn out, standing water and aggressive water (acidic, or high in chlorides) do damage too. Water chemistry problems tend to affect a whole neighborhood or region rather than one house.
So a leak in one house and none next door points away from the water supply. The program's plumbing expert, Richard Trethewey, has a plumber cut out the failed section for lab analysis, and he says the Copper Development Association can help find the cause or refer a firm that specializes in corrosion.
Where corrosion is widespread, This Old House says replacement may be needed. Where copper meets steel, for example at a boiler, a dielectric union keeps the two metals from touching and stops corrosion at the joint. Trethewey also says to replace the water heater's anode rod every three to five years.
Why it matters: A repipe is a big bill for an owner and a big job for a plumber. Lab results on the failed piece and a check on whether neighbors have the same leaks show whether the trouble is one bad joint or the water in the whole system.
Sources
- How to Stop Copper Pipe CorrosionThis Old House, May 27
- Pinhole leak - time for re-pipe?Reddit r/Plumbing, Nov 15