Edition
Sunday, November 22
Updated
1:06 PM EST

Fails & scandalsJapan

Tama Home branch booked fake fire insurance payouts as construction sales, internal report says

A branch of Tama Home Co., the Tokyo-based homebuilder, filed about 250 made-up fire insurance claims and about 90 padded ones starting around 2020, then logged the payouts as construction revenue, Kyodo News reported, citing the company's own internal report.

Kyodo said it obtained the report Tama Home put together when the problem first surfaced. The company sells fire insurance as an agent, and the document was sent to the insurers it works with. The three that paid on the claims are Tokio Marine & Nichido Fire, Mitsui Sumitomo Insurance and Sompo Japan.

The review went through records of the Takamatsu branch, on the island of Shikoku, back to about 2020 and found the cheating had been repeated since at least then. Staff reused photos from earlier claims to make it look as if homes had damage that needed repair work. In the padded claims, the bill was higher than what the work really cost. Several employees admitted taking part, Kyodo reported.

The report also points at pay. Staff could earn performance bonuses tied to the orders they booked, and the report says that system may have been one of the things that encouraged the fraud. Money from the made-up claims went into the books as payment for construction work.

NHK reported on Nov. 11 that the suspect claims ran to several hundred and topped 20 million yen. Neither report said what the insurers or regulators plan to do next, or whether other branches were reviewed.

Why it matters: Insurance repair jobs get approved on photos and estimates. Contractors who handle insurance-paid work and pay staff by booked orders should note that this report names exactly that kind of bonus as one cause of the fraud.

Sources

More in fails & scandals