Edition
Sunday, November 22
Updated
1:06 PM EST

Fails & scandalsAU

Smart Built fined A$150,000 after 30 tonnes of precast wall fell onto a neighbor's home in Adelaide

Smart Built Pty Ltd, a South Australian builder, has been fined A$150,000 because it had temporary props taken off 10-meter precast concrete wall panels with no engineer's approval. Thirteen days later about 30 tonnes of wall fell onto the house next door in Wayville, hurting a mother and her child, SafeWork SA said.

The South Australian Employment Court convicted the company on November 5 on its guilty plea to a Category 2 charge under the state's Work Health and Safety Act 2012, the regulator said. Smart Built was the principal contractor on a three-story residential building in the Adelaide suburb of Wayville. It was the company's first job with precast panels, the court found.

The panels, about 10 meters high, stood on temporary propping until they could be tied into the permanent structure. Smart Built asked for the props to come out because they were in the way of parts of the site. They were removed on November 15, 2023, and no engineer had certified that it was safe. On November 28, three panels fell outward onto the home at 118 Rose Terrace. The mother needed stitches in her knee and the child had superficial cuts.

An expert who gave evidence for SafeWork SA found the props were pulled before an adequate lateral bracing system was in place, and that the wall could not have stood up to even moderate wind. In sentencing, Deputy President Lieschke noted the company was aware that no engineer had signed off, and described this as a "stark failure". The fine includes a 40% discount for the early guilty plea. The company also owes a A$451 victims of crime levy and A$1,210 of the regulator's legal costs.

US crews work under a similar rule. OSHA's precast concrete standard, 29 CFR 1926.704(a), says precast wall units, structural framing and tilt-up panels must be supported against overturning and collapse until the permanent connections are finished.

Why it matters: Props and braces on precast and tilt-up panels come out only when the engineer of record says the structure can carry the load. On this job the props went to clear access, the wall stood unbraced for 13 days, and 30 tonnes landed in a neighbor's house.

Sources

More in fails & scandals