Pontins owner fined £1 million over Brean Sands ceiling collapse that killed a grandmother
Britannia Jinky Jersey Ltd, the parent company of Pontins, was fined £1 million at Bristol Crown Court over the 2019 ceiling collapse at Pontins Brean Sands in Somerset that led to the death of Wendy Jones, 68. Contractor Stephen Bennison got a 10-month suspended sentence.
Mr Justice Moody sentenced both on Friday, Nov. 20, after each admitted an offence under the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974. The company must also pay £72,345 in prosecution costs. Bennison, 60, of Farington in Lancashire, got 10 months in prison suspended for 18 months and £1,000 in costs. The company had first been charged with corporate manslaughter, which it denied, and prosecutors accepted the safety plea instead, the Somerset County Gazette reported.
Ventilation ducting and part of the ceiling came down during bingo in the Fun Factory hall on Feb. 20, 2019. Jones, from Hereford, spent almost six months in hospital and died that August. The investigation by Avon and Somerset Police, Somerset Council and the Health and Safety Executive found the ducting had been badly installed decades earlier, before Pontins took over, the Guardian reported. The direct cause was soundproofing work done in 2015 and 2016.
Bennison ran a sound and lighting business, had never done a soundproofing job that size and held no structural qualifications. He wrote no method statement or risk assessment and brought in tradesmen with no soundproofing experience, the judge said. More than four tonnes of leftover slabs and plasterboard went on top of the ducting, according to the Gazette. A chartered surveyor warned in 2016 that the work could bring the ceiling down, and Bennison essentially dismissed the report, the judge said. He added: "I find that Mr Bennison was engaged because he was cheaper."
In the days before the collapse, guests saw the ceiling bulging and told staff, but the reports went no further. Paul Streets, chief executive of Britannia Hotels Group, said the company was deeply sorry and has since changed its procedures for outside contractors and staff training.
Earlier: Pontins ceiling collapse: contractor and parent company admit safety offence over Brean Sands
Why it matters: A client that picks the cheapest contractor without checking competence shares the blame in court. Before anything is stacked on ducts, ceiling grids or hangers, get the load checked in writing, and treat a surveyor's warning or a visible sag as a stop-work signal.
Sources
- Pontins Brean Sands fined £1m after holidaymaker's deathSomerset County Gazette, Nov 20
- Pontins owner fined £1m over death of woman at Somerset holiday parkThe Guardian, Nov 20
- 'Disregard for health and safety' Leyland man sentenced after Pontins ceiling collapse which killed granLancashire Evening Post, Nov 20