Edition
Sunday, November 22
Updated
1:06 PM EST

Fails & scandals

Lake Purdy Dam: Central Alabama Water votes to settle $1.4 million fee fight with Arcadis

Central Alabama Water, the restructured Birmingham-area water utility, voted Nov. 13 to settle a lawsuit in which Arcadis claims about $1.4 million in unpaid engineering fees, after the utility dropped the firm and the Lake Purdy Dam rehabilitation stalled.

The terms have not been made public. Arcadis sued in September, arguing that the utility held back payment for engineering work already done and made payment depend on handing over project records from a 22-year relationship, ENR reported, citing WBHM. According to ENR, the board vote alone does not show that a final agreement was signed or that the case was dismissed.

Arcadis was the utility's consulting engineer for more than two decades and ran construction management on the Lake Purdy Dam job, once estimated at about $86 million. After a governance overhaul ordered by the state, the board picked Jacobs as its new consulting engineer. In July 2025 an Arcadis senior vice president had warned directors that digging into the downstream slope left the dam temporarily less stable. Work stopped in late December. The utility said contractor Thalle Construction demobilized Dec. 23. Thalle said it was still on site until a Jan. 2 order to stop.

In March, Jacobs told the board the dam itself was essentially unchanged, but spillway training walls that had been partly torn down for new work left the spillway less able to pass floodwater without eroding the riverbanks. The fix was to rebuild the walls, protect bare ground against erosion, add a weir wall to cut downstream scour and install monitoring instruments. Stantec became engineer of record for that work. The board cut fiscal 2026 spending on the dam from $22 million to $7.7 million.

By June 8 the left wall was finished and Thalle was placing roller-compacted concrete on the right one, with about $2.4 million spent. Jacobs projected substantial completion by July 31 and closeout in September. The utility did not answer ENR on whether that happened or when permanent rehabilitation will resume. Lake Purdy carries a high-hazard rating, which reflects what a failure would cost downstream, not the dam's condition.

Why it matters: Halting a dam job partway through excavation can leave the structure weaker than before work began. Consultants and contractors on public work should check how their contracts tie payment to handing over project records if the owner changes engineers.

Sources

More in fails & scandals