Galliard Canning Town towers: director said denying a threat to life would be foolhardy, letters show
A Galliard Homes director told residents of the evacuated Royal Gateway towers in Canning Town, east London, that it would be foolish to deny a threat to life from the cracked transfer slabs, according to lawyers' letters seen by Inside Housing. Galliard says the remarks were taken out of context.
The meeting took place on 22 October, the day the first three towers were emptied. Letters from lawyers for the leaseholders' right to manage company quote Darren Maguire, Galliard's managing director for construction, after he looked at the cracks. He called it “absolutely foolhardy and ridiculous” to claim there was no threat to life, the letters say, and added that he expected to be “suing people after this.” A Galliard spokesperson told Inside Housing the quotes were selective and should not be read as admissions about the cause of the defects or about liability.
Inside Housing also saw a report by Conisbee, the structural engineers hired by the residents' company. It describes extensive diagonal cracking on the underside of the second-floor transfer slab around a column the slab carries. Conisbee rated the risk as high and said the building should not be occupied. A transfer slab picks up columns from the floors above and passes their load to columns on a different grid below. If it is too weak, a column can punch through it. Engineers for Galliard, Newham Council and the residents have not yet agreed on the risk or on what repairs would let people return.
Galliard and Cathedral built the complex between 2013 and 2016 through a joint venture, with Hale Allen Jones, now HA Consulting, as structural engineer, Inside Housing reported. HA Consulting did not respond. The building's insurer treats the problem as a build defect and has refused cover, and Prime Property Management, which runs the blocks, has opened talks with the National House Building Council, which issued 10-year warranties on the flats.
Galliard has now hired the Insurance Claims Accommodation Bureau to book temporary housing and pay for it directly, at first for up to three months, without admitting liability. Residents of 211 homes left three blocks on 22 October and 115 residents left two more a week later. Thirteen businesses in the complex, including a climbing centre, remain shut.
Earlier: Newham orders emergency works at Galliard's Canning Town towers as all five blocks stand empty
Why it matters: Transfer slabs sit in podium towers on both sides of the Atlantic. This case shows the claim running from developer to structural engineer of record to warranty provider, so design calcs, slab inspection records and site changes to penetrations near columns are what everyone will ask for first.
If this affects you
- Newham Council says its dangerous structure notices on the Canning Town blocks remain in force and urges anyone still living in them to leave. newham.gov.uk
- Newham Council served the dangerous structure notices on 29 October for Centurion Tower, Sovereign Tower and St Vincent's Court and has published them. newham.gov.uk
Sources
- ‘Foolhardy’ not to acknowledge risk to life after viewing cracks at evacuated buildings, director at developer saysInside Housing, Nov 20