Edition
Sunday, November 22
Updated
1:06 PM EST

BusinessUK

FRC review finds UK contractors vague on disputed payments, delay penalties and loss-making jobs

The Financial Reporting Council, the UK's accounting regulator, looked at the annual reports of nine contractors and six housebuilders and found that disclosure of uncertain contract income, delay damages and overrun risk generally fell short. It published the thematic review on November 18.

Only five of the nine contractors mentioned liquidated damages at all, even though penalties for late completion are routine in building contracts, Construction Enquirer reported. Five contractors called their revenue and cost forecasts significant estimates, and just two of them showed how a change in those forecasts would move their results. Some reported a single provision that mixed money set aside for jobs expected to lose money with defect and warranty costs, which hides where future hits could come from.

Housebuilders had gaps of their own. Three of the six gave no provisions for warranties, remedial work or costs still owed on finished sites, which the FRC called unusual. One company that signed the Building Safety Repairs Pledge neither booked a provision nor said why. None put a value on the land options sitting in its inventory.

The regulator also named good practice. Balfour Beatty set out possible results on a handful of long-term contracts, from an £82 million gain to a £44 million loss. Morgan Sindall explained how variations, delay penalties and disputed payments feed into its revenue. Persimmon said a 20% swing in estimated costs on remediation schemes not yet contracted could change its provision by £17.2 million. Building safety liabilities were generally explained better: seven companies carried such provisions.

The FRC wants clearer reporting when these companies next publish results. Its sample was 15 companies, some listed and some private, and it looked only at what they disclosed. It did not test whether reported profits were right and did not examine liquidity or going concern.

Why it matters: Disputed claims and delay damages are where a contractor's reported profit can turn into a loss. Subcontractors and suppliers checking a main contractor's accounts can look for these notes, and a vague one gives them little to judge the risk by.

Sources

More in business