Edition
Sunday, November 22
Updated
1:06 PM EST

Fails & scandalsAU

Footscray's Buckingham Hotel apartments: owners pay $1.9 million for defect repairs after builder settlement stalls

Owners of 22 apartments at the former Buckingham Hotel pub in Footscray, Melbourne, are funding a $1.896 million repair job themselves. A VCAT case against the builder settled for $175,000, and the owners corporation says only $100,000 of it has been paid, Nine.com.au reported.

The pub was redeveloped in 2012 and 2013, with most units in a new extension behind it and four inside the old hotel. Owners moved in from 2014. Leaks and peeling varnish on the cladding showed up by 2017. A full inspection in 2021 found glass balustrades that flexed, balcony screens and partition walls coming loose, failed waterproofing on the walkways, rusting steel in the stairwell, faulty roof plumbing, timber cladding with no fire rating and missing gas isolation valves.

Quotes ran as high as about $3 million. The owners corporation signed a $1.896 million contract, financed with a strata loan, and work that began in July is due to finish in mid-December. Individual levies run from $30,000 to $150,000, split by units of liability, since Victoria charges owners by benefit rather than in equal shares. Scaffolding alone cost $200,000. One couple who paid $290,000 for a one-bedroom unit in 2014 now expect their share to reach about $150,000.

The owners spent four years at VCAT before settling with the builder, whom Nine said it could not name for legal reasons, for $175,000 in seven quarterly payments ending in October. The Building and Plumbing Commission has suspended the builder's registration over a missing letter of eligibility for insurance and unpaid registration fees. Maribyrnong City Council said a private building surveyor issued the permit, so the council did no inspections during construction.

Since July the commission can order builders back to fix defective, incomplete or non-compliant work for up to 10 years after the occupancy permit. It told Nine the power does not reach back to buildings like this one.

Why it matters: The owners corporation chair said repair prices climbed about 30% and then 30% again while the tribunal case ran. Builders in Victoria now face rectification orders for up to a decade after the occupancy permit, issued whether or not an insurance policy applies.

Sources

More in fails & scandals