C.D. Smith wins Milwaukee's stalled Neutral Edison tower site with a $3 million sheriff's sale bid
C.D. Smith, the Fond du Lac contractor still owed about $11.3 million for work on Neutral's planned 31-story Edison mass timber tower in Milwaukee, was the only bidder at an Oct. 19 sheriff's sale and offered $3 million for the site, Urban Milwaukee reported.
The sale of the riverfront lot at 1005 N. Edison St. is not final yet. C.D. Smith filed a motion on Monday asking a judge to confirm it, and Judge Jon Richards has a hearing set for Dec. 14. The auction platform Bid4Assets listed the contractor as the sole bidder.
The bid follows a foreclosure suit C.D. Smith brought in March against Neutral and its affiliates. The contractor says it performed roughly $13.67 million of work and was paid $2.37 million. In June a Milwaukee County judge entered a default judgment for C.D. Smith after Neutral failed to file a valid response: CEO Nate Helbach had argued the dispute belonged in mediation or arbitration under the construction contract, but he is not a lawyer and could not represent the company, so the filing was struck. A foreclosure judgment of about $11.79 million followed on Sept. 4. As the foreclosing creditor, C.D. Smith may be able to apply that judgment toward the price instead of paying cash, subject to the court.
Neutral broke ground in spring 2025 on the roughly $205 million, 353-unit tower, promoted as the tallest mass timber building in the Western Hemisphere. Work stopped in September 2025 with only part of the foundation in place. Neutral blamed inflation, tariffs and rising costs. City officials later put the financing gap at about $25 million, and the estimated cost had reportedly climbed to at least $230 million. Contractors have filed more than $14 million in claims tied to the project.
C.D. Smith has not said whether it will develop the site, bring in a partner or sell the land. Several developers told Urban Milwaukee they had looked at taking over the project, but industry sources said the liens and the foreclosure case had to be settled first.
Why it matters: A general contractor left unpaid on a stalled tower may end up owning the dirt, and here the only bid is $3 million against an $11.79 million judgment. Check your lien deadlines and your contract's dispute clause before an owner's money runs out.
Sources
- C.D. Smith Wins Auction For Stalled Edison Tower SiteUrban Milwaukee, Nov 17