Bujeon-Masan tunnel collapse caused by grouting at 20 times the safe pressure, Korean probe finds
South Korea's land ministry says the 2020 collapse of the Nakdong No. 1 tunnel on the Bujeon-Masan rail line was caused by grout pumped at up to 9,000 kPa, against a limit of about 450 kPa, after builder SK ecoplant's crews kept working through cracks and leaks.
A government investigation committee of 12 outside experts, set up in February, released its findings on November 19 in Sejong, Korean outlets including Seoul Shinmun and Etoday reported. The collapse hit at about 4:28 a.m. on March 18, 2020, while crews dug cross passage No. 3 beneath Busan's Sasang district. Groundwater and soil flooded in, damaged the main tunnel and opened a sinkhole at the surface. Nobody was hurt. The 32.7 km private rail line between Busan and Gimhae was 96% complete and due to open that June. It still has not opened.
According to the committee, the contractor picked a compaction grouting method to seal gaps in older deep soil mixing columns but never checked its effect on nearby structures or ran trial injections to set pressure and volume. The committee put the safe injection pressure at about 450 kPa. Records showed up to 9,000 kPa, and handwritten logs did not match the automatic ones. Crews spotted cracks and leaking joints in the main tunnel on March 8. They kept grouting, the damage spread, and the tunnel failed 10 days later.
The committee also found weak spots in the older soil columns and a design check that modeled passage No. 4 instead of the riskier No. 3. Two earlier probes run by concessionaire Smart Rail, formed by an SK ecoplant-led group, had blamed bad ground and called the collapse force majeure, Hankook Ilbo reported.
The ministry expects the final report in about a month and will then weigh penalty points and business suspensions for the builder and the supervising firm. The two unbuilt cross passages will shrink from 3.6 m to 2.0 m across. Partial service is targeted for April 2027; there is no date for the full line.
Why it matters: Grouting next to a live tunnel or foundation needs a trial run, a pressure limit and a stop rule. Here crews tracked grout volume, ignored pressure and kept pumping after cracks showed. Check that your grouting specs set maximum pressure and that logs are reviewed daily.
Sources
- '불가항력'이라던 부전~마산선 터널 붕괴…정부 조사서 시공 관리 부실 드러나Etoday, Nov 19
- '불가항력'이라던 부전마산 복선전철 붕괴… 정부 사조위 "시공 부실"Hankook Ilbo, Nov 19
- 허용치 20배 시멘트 주입 압력…부전마산선 터널 붕괴 불렀다Seoul Shinmun, Nov 19
- 균열 보고도 공사 강행…부전~마산 터널 붕괴 원인 드러났다Seoul Economic Daily, Nov 19