Brooklyn building collapse: city orders the dig next door partly backfilled and brings in an independent engineer
New York's Department of Buildings on Nov. 17 ordered parts of the excavation at 2625 Bedford Avenue filled back in and stopped debris removal at 1321 Flatbush Avenue, where eight people died, until an outside forensic engineer joins the investigation, ENR reports.
The agency also ordered shoring put in inside 1325 Flatbush Avenue and more stability inspections at 1323 Flatbush, according to ENR. The stop-work order on the Bedford Avenue lot stays in force, and only work that keeps the site safe or helps investigators is allowed. Crews will resume clearing the rubble once the independent consultant arrives, in a way that leaves room for the forensic review.
Public records still leave the central engineering questions open, ENR found after going through the approved plans. They do not show whether the building that fell on Nov. 11 had been underpinned, how deep the dig reached along the property line, or which parts of the approved excavation support were in place. On Nov. 16 the department said the south side of the site was dug using benching, a sloped cut, but it did not say whether the building was underpinned.
The plans called for baseline readings before digging and continued tracking of movement, cracks and vibration at neighboring buildings, with limits that would require a notice or a halt. None of that monitoring data has been released. Neither have the special inspection reports for sheeting, shoring and bracing; after the collapse the city portal listed that inspection as identified but not certified. A March 5 preconstruction survey said details of the old building's foundation had not been provided, and during plan review the city asked the engineer of record, from LMW Engineering Group, to add the neighbors' foundation materials and elevations to the drawings.
Gothamist reported on Nov. 17 that inspectors had checked at least 24 jobs in four boroughs tied to the project's engineer and its special inspector, with full or partial stop-work orders at five or more. No cause has been announced and no one has been charged.
Why it matters: Any sub digging next to an old lot-line building in New York should expect investigators to ask for baseline readings, crack and movement logs and signed special inspection reports. Check that yours exist and match the approved support-of-excavation drawings.
Sources
- Brooklyn building collapse: Mamdani announces inspections at 100 sites linked to disaster that killed 8, including 2 childrenamNewYork, Nov 12
- Flatbush building collapse violationsCBS News New York, Nov 13
- Brooklyn Collapse Records Reveal Gap Between Plans and Site WorkENR, Nov 17