Edition
Sunday, November 22
Updated
1:06 PM EST

Fails & scandalsUK

Banbury building collapse keeps Cherwell Street partly closed nearly a month on as councillor blames HSE

A county councillor in Banbury, Oxfordshire, says the Health and Safety Executive is holding the town "to ransom" because the A4260 Cherwell Street is still partly closed almost four weeks after a block of flats under construction partly collapsed with its scaffolding on Oct. 21.

Two workers went to hospital after the collapse. Construction Enquirer reported that nine people were working on the site, a former car sales garage next to a Morrisons petrol station that is being rebuilt as 19 flats. South Central Ambulance Service said one worker had head and leg injuries. The other was badly hurt and was taken to the John Radcliffe Hospital in Oxford with the Thames Valley Air Ambulance critical care team.

The road was shut for nine days, the BBC reported, then reopened with two temporary lanes running in opposite directions. Residents and bus companies complained about delays, and last week Cherwell District Council changed the layout again and closed the road to all northbound traffic. Only the southbound lane farthest from the building is open. The council says lanes nearer the site will reopen once the site is made safe. The site sits close to the junction with Bridge Street, one of the town's busiest crossroads, used by traffic heading to Grimsbury, the M40 and the town centre.

Paul-Austin Sargent, who represents Grimsbury on Oxfordshire County Council, told the BBC that the agency's communication with residents was "not good enough" and that little had been said in public about timescales or contingency plans. The HSE said its inspectors are investigating the cause and advising the contractor, which is responsible for making the site safe. Reports have not named the developer or the contractor, and no date for a full reopening has been given.

Why it matters: When a frame under construction fails beside a main road, the contractor owns the make-safe work and the closure lasts as long as that work does. Teams building next to live traffic should know who signs off temporary works and scaffold design, and have a make-safe plan the council can share.

Sources

More in fails & scandals